The first company car
Correct taxation and structuring models


When an employee receives a company car for the first time, the excitement is often considerable. But a company car also raises many questions: How is the company car benefit taxed and how can it be reduced? Is a logbook worthwhile? What effect do employee contributions and privately borne costs have? Is a cheaper vehicle class or an electric vehicle financially attractive? These and other questions are answered below.
1. Initial scenario
Employee A – single, with no church affiliation and no children – has been promoted. While this does not increase his gross salary (previously 4,000 EUR in tax class I (Steuerklasse I)), he may now choose a company car, which he is also allowed to use privately without restriction. After some research, A intends to choose a new car (combustion engine) with a gross list price (Bruttolistenneupreis, BLP) of 40,000 EUR and factory-fitted optional extras (10,000 EUR gross).
However, A wonders what tax consequences the company car will have for him. After all, he now saves the costs of all private journeys, and his employer will from now on also cover his daily commute to work (a distance of 20 km).
2. Flat-rate taxation
Because the employer bears all the costs, A can in theory drive the company car free of charge. Nevertheless, the company car places an effective burden on A, because it constitutes a benefit in kind (Sachbezug) that is subject to tax and social security contributions.
Under § 8 (2) sentence 2 of the Income Tax Act (Einkommensteuergesetz, EStG) in conjunction with § 6 (1) no. 4 sentence 2 EStG, the non-cash benefit (geldwerter Vorteil) is generally determined using the flat-rate one-percent rule. A's gross salary therefore increases as follows:
| Private use | |
| BLP | 40,000 EUR |
| plus optional extras | 10,000 EUR |
| Total | 50,000 EUR |
| × 1 % (= benefit in kind per month) | 500 EUR |
Please note | For the one-percent rule, the relevant figure is always the BLP at the time of first registration. This also applies to used cars and even if the actual purchase price is lower due to discounts. Only optional extras fitted retrospectively (after first registration) are disregarded when determining the benefit in kind.
As the company car can also be used for journeys between home and the primary place of work (erste Tätigkeitsstätte), § 8 (2) sentence 3 EStG requires a monthly surcharge of 0.03 % of the BLP plus optional extras for each kilometre of distance between home and the primary place of work.
| Home/primary place of work | |
| BLP plus optional extras | 50,000 EUR |
| × 0.03 % | 15 EUR |
| × distance to primary place of work (20 km) | 300 EUR |
Please note | If the company car can also be used for a dual household (doppelte Haushaltsführung), a flat rate of 0.002 % of the BLP plus optional extras must be applied for each journey per kilometre of distance between the location of the employee's own household and the place of employment (§ 8 (2) sentence 5 EStG). However, this only applies to journeys for which no income-related expenses (Werbungskosten) are deductible, i.e. whenever the employee travels to the second home more than once a week.
For A, the company car effectively results in two changes: he no longer bears the vehicle costs directly, and his gross salary subject to tax and contributions rises from 4,000 EUR to 4,800 EUR. This reduces his net income: whereas his employer previously paid him a net salary of 2,602 EUR, this will fall to 2,222 EUR in future.
KEY POINT | The company car therefore effectively costs A 380 EUR net per month. He must deduct this amount from the car costs he saves, because the company car only creates a genuine financial advantage to the extent of the difference.
Given this burden (380 EUR per month), it is worth considering how it can be reduced. There are several options.
3. A cheaper vehicle
The simplest way to reduce the financial burden is for A to choose a company car with a lower BLP.
| Example |
A opts for a cheaper company car. Its BLP including optional extras at the time of first registration is no longer 50,000 EUR but only 40,000 EUR. Thanks to the lower BLP, the benefit in kind for private journeys falls to 400 EUR per month (40,000 EUR × 1 %) and for journeys to work to 240 EUR (40,000 EUR × 0.03 % × 20 km). The gross salary thus rises from 4,000 EUR to only 4,640 EUR (previously 4,800 EUR). As the net salary is now 2,300 EUR, A receives 78 EUR more net pay per month. |
KEY POINT | This also saves the employer money. Firstly, the company car (purchase or leasing) costs less. Secondly, the employer saves around 20 % in employer social security contributions on the reduced gross salary each month. With a difference of 160 EUR as in the example (previously 4,800 EUR, now 4,640 EUR), that still amounts to 32 EUR per month.
4. Electric or hybrid electric vehicles
The benefit in kind can also be reduced by choosing an electric or hybrid electric vehicle instead of a combustion engine. Because the state also wants to promote electric mobility through the tax system, these vehicles qualify for reductions affecting the BLP under the conditions set out in § 6 (1) no. 4 sentence 2 EStG. If, for example, a purely electric vehicle with zero carbon dioxide emissions is chosen as the company car, and the BLP is no more than 60,000 EUR for vehicles first provided by the employer after 31.12.2018 and before 1.1.2031 (increased to 70,000 EUR by the Growth Opportunities Act (Wachstumschancengesetz) for acquisitions after 31.12.2023), only one quarter of the BLP rather than the full amount is applied, which reduces the benefit in kind.
If an electric vehicle exceeds the 60,000 EUR or 70,000 EUR threshold, the BLP is not quartered but halved – a rule that also applies to hybrid electric vehicles. For vehicles first provided by the employer after 31.12.2021 and before 1.1.2025, the condition is that the hybrid electric vehicle has carbon dioxide emissions of no more than 50 g per kilometre driven or a range of at least 60 km using the electric motor alone (80 km after 31.12.2024 and before 1.1.2031).
| Example |
A opts for a cheaper company car. Its BLP including optional extras at the time of first registration is no longer 50,000 EUR but only 40,000 EUR. Thanks to the lower BLP, the benefit in kind for private journeys falls to 400 EUR per month (40,000 EUR × 1 %) and for journeys to work to 240 EUR (40,000 EUR × 0.03 % × 20 km). The gross salary thus rises from 4,000 EUR to only 4,640 EUR (previously 4,800 EUR). As the net salary is now 2,300 EUR, A receives 78 EUR more net pay per month. |
PRACTICAL TIPS | A (hybrid) electric company car requires a charging device (e.g. a wallbox). Under § 3 no. 46 EStG and § 1 (1) of the Social Insurance Remuneration Ordinance (Sozialversicherungsentgeltverordnung), the employer can provide this to the employee free of tax and contributions. However, the employer remains the owner. If ownership is to pass to the employee, the transfer of the charging device constitutes a benefit in kind. The tax can then be paid by the employer at a flat rate of 25 % (§ 40 (2) sentence 1 no. 6 EStG). The advantage: no social security contributions are due.
Since the employee uses their private electricity when charging at home, the employer can reimburse this free of tax and contributions. In principle, individual proof of the electricity consumed is required. For simplification, however, the tax authorities (BMF letter of 29.9.2020, ref. IV C 5 – S 2334/19/10009 :004, para. 24) also permit flat rates.
The amount depends on whether the vehicle is an electric or a hybrid electric vehicle and whether the employee can also charge at the employer's premises:
- with additional charging facility at the employer: 30 EUR per month for electric vehicles and 15 EUR for hybrid electric vehicles,
- without additional charging facility at the employer: 70 EUR per month for electric vehicles and 35 EUR for hybrid electric vehicles.
5. Individual valuation of journeys to work
The flat rate applied so far to journeys between home and the primary place of work does not take individual driving behaviour into account, nor how often the primary place of work was actually visited.
This becomes a problem if the employee makes only a few journeys due to working from home or in the field, part-time work, holidays, illness, etc. Such periods of non-use are already factored into the flat-rate usage value, so the benefit in kind cannot be reduced (cf. BMF letter of 3.3.2022, ref. IV C 5 – S 2334/21/10004 :001, para. 12). This even applies to full calendar months in which the company car was not actually used for journeys between home and the primary place of work.
| Example |
| Due to a prolonged illness and various periods of working from home, A uses his company car (BLP: 50,000 EUR) for only 100 journeys a year between home and the primary place of work. Regardless of the number of journeys actually made, the benefit in kind amounts to 3,600 EUR (50,000 EUR × 0.03 % × 20 km × 12). |
This unfair result can be avoided, however, because the journeys actually made can be valued individually instead of using the flat-rate method. Note that this option can only be exercised for the entire year and that each journey is valued at 0.002 % of the BLP. Individual valuation pays off if the employee travels between home and the primary place of work on fewer than 180 days in the calendar year (12 months × 0.03 % = 0.36 %; 180 days × 0.002 % also equals 0.36 %).
| Example |
| As in the previous example, but A applies for individual valuation: the benefit in kind falls from 3,600 EUR to 2,000 EUR (50,000 EUR × 0.002 % × 20 km × 100 journeys). Assuming 20 % social security contributions and 30 % tax, this means a saving of 800 EUR net per year (1,600 EUR × 50 %). |
The tax authorities have set out the requirements for individual valuation in para. 13 (BMF 3.3.2022, loc. cit.). According to this, A must declare to the employer in writing, for each calendar month and each vehicle, on which days (stating the dates) he actually used the company car for journeys between home and the primary place of work; merely stating the number of days is not sufficient. By contrast, the Nuremberg Fiscal Court (Finanzgericht Nürnberg, 23.1.2020, ref. 4 K 1789/18) takes the view that stating the dates is not strictly necessary.
No information is required on how the employee travelled to the primary place of work on the other working days. Days on which the employee makes several journeys with the company car (e.g. because of going home for lunch) count as one day.
The employer must keep the employee's written declaration with the payroll account (Lohnkonto). For the sake of simplicity, it is acceptable to base the calculation of the benefit in kind on the previous month's declaration.
Please note | To ensure that individual valuation does not lead to a higher benefit in kind, the employer must apply an annual cap of 180 journeys in total.
Individual valuation is an option. However, the employer must apply it if the employee requests it. The employer can only avoid this obligation by including a clause in the employment contract or in the company car agreement stating that it is not required to carry out individual valuation. In this case, the employee can switch to individual valuation in their income tax return and reduce their gross salary. To do so, the employee must state, with dates, on which days they used the company car for journeys between home and the primary place of work and the amount of the benefit in kind taken into account by the employer.
KEY POINT | Retrospective individual valuation reduces income tax. Social security contributions, however, remain unchanged.
6. Cost cap
The benefits in kind calculated on a flat-rate basis must not exceed the total costs of the company car; otherwise, tax would be levied on a benefit that did not actually arise. It is therefore necessary to compare the total benefit in kind determined for the year with the vehicle costs actually incurred (including insurance, vehicle tax, fuel, repairs and depreciation). If the vehicle costs exceed the benefit in kind, the latter must be reduced by the difference.
| Example |
| A's employer has compiled the total vehicle costs. They amount to 8,000 EUR. Since the benefit in kind recorded as salary for the year so far amounts to 9,600 EUR, it must be reduced by 1,600 EUR. |
7. Logbook
If A keeps a proper logbook (Fahrtenbuch) (BMF 3.3.2022, loc. cit., para. 26 et seq.), the actual vehicle costs can be applied instead of the flat-rate benefits in kind. To do this, the total annual costs of the company car are determined, divided by the total annual mileage, and the resulting rate per kilometre is multiplied by each kilometre driven privately (and likewise for journeys to the primary place of work). This method is particularly worthwhile for a high BLP and/or if the company car is used little for private purposes.
| Example |
The benefits in kind for the company car amount to 9,600 EUR per year. A has kept a logbook, which shows 20,000 km driven (8,000 private, 8,000 business and 4,000 for journeys between home and the primary place of work). The total vehicle costs were calculated at 12,000 EUR (including depreciation over eight years). |
Concessions are available for a (hybrid) electric vehicle (§ 6 (1) no. 4 sentence 3 EStG). Depending on the type of vehicle, the depreciation included in the total costs is applied at only one half or one quarter. The result: a lower cost rate per km and a lower benefit in kind.
The logbook must allow the entries to be checked easily and reliably. All journeys must be recorded separately, continuously and promptly. For private journeys, the kilometres together with the date and the note "private" must be entered. For journeys between home and the primary place of work, stating the date, the mileage readings and the note "home/primary place of work" is sufficient. For business journeys, the date and mileage readings, the destination and purpose of the journey and the name of the business partner must be documented.
The logbook must be kept in a closed form and in such a way that it cannot be manipulated and any changes are visible. Electronic logbooks are permitted if they provide the same information as a manually kept logbook and any subsequent change to entries without documentation is impossible. A simple Excel file does not meet the requirements for a proper logbook.
8. Employee contributions
Contributions and usage fees payable to the employer have one thing in common: they reduce the usage value and thus the benefit in kind (Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) 30.11.2016, ref. VI R 49/14 and ref. VI R 2/15). The reason: to the extent of the usage fee, the employee is not enriched by being provided with the company car, so no salary arises in that amount.
KEY POINT | If the usage fee exceeds the benefit in kind, the excess amount results neither in negative salary nor in income-related expenses.
8.1 One-off contribution to the acquisition costs
If the employee makes a one-off contribution to the acquisition costs or pays a special leasing payment, these often substantial amounts reduce the benefit in kind down to 0 EUR (R 8.1 (9) no. 4 sentences 2 and 3 of the Wage Tax Guidelines (Lohnsteuerrichtlinien, LStR)). Because of the high payment, the amount often exceeds the benefit in kind. This excess is not lost, however, but can be carried forward to future periods.
| Example | |||
| As A wants a more expensive vehicle than his employer is willing to provide, he contributes 15,000 EUR towards the acquisition costs. The annual benefit in kind under the one-percent method is 9,600 EUR. The contribution is offset against the benefit in kind. Any excess is carried forward to future years: | |||
| Year | Benefit in kind | Contribution | Taxable |
| 1 | 9,600 EUR | 9,600 EUR | 0 EUR |
| 2 | 9,600 EUR | 5,400 EUR | 4,200 EUR |
| 3 et seq. | 9,600 EUR | 0 EUR | 9,600 EUR |
More articles

Welcome, Generation Z!
Attracting and retaining Generation Z: employer branding, recruiting, onboarding and HR digitalisation that resonate with young talent.
Read more
5-Step Model for HR Processes in Growing Companies
HR processes for growing companies: our 5-step model makes your people processes digital, scalable and agile – explained with practical examples.
Read more
Are Temporary Work and Interim Management Soon a Thing of the Past?
Find out why temporary work and interim management are changing – trends, opportunities and risks for companies in Germany.
Read moreLet's talk about your situation.
In a free initial consultation we will clarify where you stand and which approach suits your situation.
